
American
PIE JUNKIE
1711 NW 16th St
Oklahoma City, OK 73106
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items

Strawberry Diner Slice
Flaky butter crust filled with glazed fresh strawberries & topped with real whipped cream. Best when enjoyed same day!$6.00
French Silk Slice
Flaky butter crust layered with chocolate ganache then filled with scratch-made chocolate pastry cream, whipped cream & mini chocolate chips.$6.00
Coconut Cream Slice
Flaky butter crust filled with scratch-made coconut pastry cream, topped with whipped cream & toasted coconut flakes.$6.00
Slices
Pie Slices

Apple Crumble Slice
Flaky butter crust filled with lightly sweetened granny smith cinnamon apples & topped with brown sugar oat crumble.$6.00OUT OF STOCK
Coconut Cream Slice
Flaky butter crust filled with scratch-made coconut pastry cream, topped with whipped cream & toasted coconut flakes.$6.00
Drunk Turtle Slice
Fudge pie in a graham cracker crust topped with pecan pieces & salted bourbon caramel.$6.00
French Silk Slice
Flaky butter crust layered with chocolate ganache then filled with scratch-made chocolate pastry cream, whipped cream & mini chocolate chips.$6.00
Key Lime Slice
Graham cracker crust with a tart & sweet lime filling.$6.00
Lemon Icebox Pie Slice
New! Graham cracker crust with a lemon cream cheese mousse, lemon curd & whipped cream.$6.00
PB Chocolate Slice
Graham cracker crust layered with chocolate ganache & filled with a rich peanut butter mousse & topped with extra chocolate ganache.$6.00
Peach Crumble Slice
Sliced peaches cooked into a sweet glaze and topped with brown sugar oat crumble.$6.00
Pecan Slice
Traditional pecan pie in a flaky butter crust. Tastes just like grandma's... but dare we say-- better?$6.00
Pineapple Millionaire Slice
Flaky butter crust layered with buttercream frosting and filled with a fluffy pineapple & pecan whip.$6.00
Raspberry Ripple Slice
Oreo crust layered with cream cheese mousse & raspberry sauce. Piped with a light whipped cream border.$7.00
S'More Slice
Graham cracker crust layered with chocolate ganache & toasted marshmallow. Microwave for 10-15 seconds for a melty, gooey S'mores experience!$6.00
Southern Banana Cream Slice
Vanilla Wafer crust layered with scratch-made vanilla pastry cream, sliced bananas, fresh whipped cream & vanilla wafer crumbles. Best when enjoyed right away as bananas may oxidize over time.$6.00
Strawberry Diner Slice
Flaky butter crust filled with glazed fresh strawberries & topped with real whipped cream. Best when enjoyed same day!$6.00
Cuties
Cutie Pies

6" Banana Cream Cutie Pie
6" shareable Banana Cream Cutie Pie featuring vanilla wafer crust layered with bananas and vanilla pastry cream. Topped with whipped cream & crushed vanilla wafers.$15.00
6" Birthday Cutie Pie
6" shareable Birthday Cutie Pie featuring a sprinkle + cookie crust, confetti cake batter mousse, whipped cream and more sprinkles.$15.00
6" Drunken Turtle Cutie Pie
6" shareable Drunken Turtle Cutie Pie featuring fudge filling baked in a graham crust, topped with pecan pieces & salted bourbon caramel.$15.00OUT OF STOCK6" Raspberry Ripple Cutie Pie
6" Shareable Cutie Pie featuring Oreo crust, cream cheese mousse, raspberry sauce and whipped cream.$15.00
Whole Pies
Sweet Pies

Apple Crumble WHOLE PIE
Flaky butter crust filled with lightly sweetened granny smith cinnamon apples & topped with brown sugar oat crumble. We do not recommend freezing Ready to Serve fruit crumble pies, for longer shelf life choose Frozen Take & Bake.$30.00
Birthday Pie WHOLE PIE
Cookie & sprinkle crust filled with confetti cake batter mousse, topped with whipped cream & more sprinkles.$34.00
Cherry Crumble WHOLE PIE
Flaky butter crust filled with tart & sweet cherries cooked into a thick, sweet glaze. Contains almond extract. Topped with brown sugar oat crumble. Best within 3 days of purchase. We do not recommend freezing Ready to Serve fruit crumble pies, for longer shelf life choose Frozen Take & Bake.$44.00
Coconut Cream WHOLE PIE
Flaky butter crust filled with scratch-made coconut pastry cream, topped with whipped cream & toasted coconut flakes. We do not recommend freezing this pie.$28.00
Drunken Turtle WHOLE PIE
Fudge pie in a graham cracker crust topped with pecan pieces & salted bourbon caramel. Freezes well for up to 3 months.$34.00
French Silk WHOLE PIE
Flaky butter crust layered with chocolate ganache then filled with scratch-made chocolate pastry cream, whipped cream & mini chocolate chips. We do not recommend freezing this pie.$34.00OUT OF STOCK
Frozen Salted Caramel Pie
New! Frozen Salted Caramel ice cream pie in a buttery pretzel crust. Keep frozen & serve frozen!$26.00
Frozen Strawberry Lemonade Pretzel Pie
Sweet, tart & creamy Strawberry Lemonade filling is frozen in our hand-pressed crunchy + salty pretzel crust. Keep frozen for up to 3 months! Serve frozen (similar to an ice cream pie.)$26.00
Key Lime w/ Whip WHOLE PIE
Graham cracker crust with a tart & sweet lime filling. Piped with a whipped cream border. We do not recommend freezing this pie.$34.00OUT OF STOCK
Lemon Icebox WHOLE PIE
Buttery graham cracker crust filled with a light lemon cream cheese mousse, lemon curd & whipped cream. Delicious & refreshing! Best within 2-3 days of purchase.$30.00
PB Chocolate WHOLE PIE
Graham cracker crust layered with chocolate ganache & filled with a rich peanut butter mousse & topped with extra chocolate ganache. Freezes well for up to 3 months.$32.00
Peach Blackberry Crumble WHOLE PIE
Flaky butter crust filled with peaches and blackberries then topped with brown sugar oat crumble.$36.00
Peach Crumble WHOLE PIE
Sliced peaches cooked into a sweet glaze and topped with brown sugar oat crumble.$30.00
Pecan WHOLE PIE
Traditional Pecan Pie in a flaky butter crust. Freezes well for up to 3 months.$28.00
S'Mores WHOLE PIE
Graham cracker crust layered with chocolate ganache and homemade toasted marshmallow. Heat each slice in the microwave for a gooey s'mores experience!$30.00
Southern Banana Cream WHOLE PIE
Vanilla wafer crust layered with vanilla pastry cream, fresh sliced bananas, whipped cream & crumbled Vanilla wafers. Best when enjoyed within 1 day of purchase.$34.00
Strawberry Diner WHOLE PIE
Flaky butter crust filled with glazed fresh strawberries & topped with real whipped cream. Best when enjoyed same day!$38.00
Quiche

Sausage Quiche WHOLE PIE
Flaky savory crust filled with egg custard, breakfast sausage, bell peppers, onions & cheddar cheese. Can be served immediately, reheated later or frozen for up to 3 months.$34.00
Spinach, Bacon & Cheddar Quiche WHOLE
Flaky savory crust filled with egg custard, chopped spinach, bacon & cheddar cheese.$34.00OUT OF STOCK
Spirit Sprinkles by Pie Junkie
Cookie Packs

Frozen Take & Bake Chocolate Chip Cookies (Dozen)
12 Frozen Take & Bake Chocolate Chip Cookies (individually portioned dough balls). Baking Instructions included - bake all or one at a time!$18.00
Frozen Take & Bake Sprinkle Cookies (Dozen)
12 Frozen Take & Bake Sprinkle Cookies (individually portioned dough balls)$18.00
Meals
Casseroles etc

Beef Shepherd's Pie
Hearty beef pie with carrots, celery, onions & peas in a savory sauce, topped with whipped potatoes. Also known as Cottage Pie. (Take & Bake)$30.00
Ham Hashbrown Casserole
Shredded hashbrowns in a creamy sauce with onions, cheddar cheese & diced ham. Topped with crunchy buttered cornflakes. Thaw before baking. (Take & Bake.)$26.00
Poppyseed Chicken Casserole
Diced chicken breast in a creamy poppyseed sauce, topped with buttered Ritz cracker crumbles. 9" family size. Thaw before baking. (Take & Bake)$30.00
French Toast Crunch Casserole
French Toast Casserole with crunchy buttered Cornflakes on top! Bakes straight from frozen. Does not contain nuts but produced in a kitchen that uses nuts.$22.00
Cheddar Sausage Balls (9)
Nine frozen take & bake oversized cheddar sausage balls. Bakes straight from the freezer in 30ish minutes. Great for breakfast or anytime... try them plain or with jam or jelly-- trust us!$20.00
Pot Pie

Chicken, Mushroom & Thyme Pot Pie
Savory butter crust with diced chicken breast, sliced mushrooms, onions & peas in a creamy mushroom thyme sauce. (Take & Bake) Small feeds 1-2 Large feeds 6+$13.00+
Chicken Pot Pie
Savory butter crust with diced chicken breast, celery, onions, carrots & peas in a creamy sauce. 9" family size. (Take & Bake) Small feeds 1-2 Large feeds 6+$13.00+
Extras
Sides

Whipped Cream Scoop
Lightly sweetened fresh whipped cream-- made from scratch daily!$1.00
Ice Cream Scoop
Make it à la mode with a scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream (comes on the side)$1.50
Salted Bourbon Caramel Shot
1 oz. shot of Salted Bourbon Caramel to drizzle over your favorite slice! We recommend it on: Southern Banana Cream, Apple Crumble & Pumpkin Crumble.$1.50
8 oz. Salted Bourbon Caramel
8 oz. container of Salted Bourbon Caramel. Freezes well! Tastes great on the Apple Crumble and Pumpkin Crumble Pies.$10.00
Drinks
Coffee
Affogato
A scoop of vanilla ice cream with a shot of hot espresso poured over the top. Intended for immediate consumption.$3.50Americano
Espresso with water$4.00Cappuccino
10 oz. Cappuccino$4.00Coffee
10 oz. hot drip coffee made with locally roasted Leap Coffee$2.50Espresso (double)
$3.00Extra Shot
Add an extra shot of espresso to any coffee drink$2.00
Hot Latte
10 oz. hot latte made with whole milk (no substitutions)$3.50Iced Americano
16 oz. iced espresso & water$4.00
Iced Junkie Brew
16 oz. iced coffee with sweetened condensed milk- similar to a Vietnamese iced coffee!$5.00Iced Latte
16 oz. iced latte made with whole milk (no substitutions)$4.00
Merch

Cookbook
$24.95
Ground Coffee
8 oz. ground 100% organic, ethically sourced Pie Junkie Blend coffee. Tasting Notes: Low acidity, full body with smooth, dark chocolate notes.$12.00
Insulated Pie Bag
Our reusable insulated pie bags come in either Teal or Pink and fit 3-4 of our pies, zipped! Perfect for traveling... just add an ice pack! Include a bag with your order and we'll send your pies home in your new favorite shopping bag.$12.00
Ceramic Mug
15 oz. Ceramic Mug$25.00
White Travel Mug
Our Pie Junkie logo is etched into the popular Simple Modern double-walled vacuum insulated travel mug. Holds 12 oz. of liquid (cold for 8 hours, hot for 2 hours), 100% stainless steel, dishwasher safe with a leak-proof lid!$30.00
Pink Ceramic Mug
12 oz. Ceramic Mug in blush pink with simple Pie Junkie lettering.$25.00
Espresso (double)
$3.00
1
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 10:00 am - 7:30 pm |
| Wednesday | 10:00 am - 7:30 pm |
| Thursday | 10:00 am - 7:30 pm |
| Friday | 10:00 am - 8:30 pm |
| Saturday | 10:00 am - 8:30 pm |
Restaurant info
We are Oklahoma City’s premier pie bakery making over 20,000 pies per year in our tiny shop. Located in the heart of the eclectic Plaza District, we bake homemade classics and fresh, original recipes from scratch each day. Whether you enjoy a slice of pie in-shop or take a whole pie to-go, we'd love to see you!
Location





