Skip to Main content
  • Pizza Boys

    • Home
    • /
    • New York Mills
    • /
    • Pizza Boys
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image
    American

    Pizza Boys

    9 Clinton St

    New York Mills, NY 13417


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Food
    Catering
    ‌
    ‌

    Featured Items

    • Large Pizza 16"

      Cheese or garlic - 8 cut
      $19.99
    • X-Large 18" Pizza & 50 Wings

      Cheese or garlic pizza - toppings extra
      $79.99
    • Seasoned Waffle Fries

      $4.99

    Food

    Pizza

    • Gluten Free Cauliflower Crust Pizza

      Personal 10" pizza - cheese or garlic - 6 cut
      $12.99
    • Personal Pizza 10"

      Cheese or garlic - 6 cut
      $11.99
    • Medium Pizza 14"

      Cheese or garlic - 8 cut
      $16.99
    • Large Pizza 16"

      Cheese or garlic - 8 cut
      $19.99
    • X-Large 18"

      Cheese or garlic - 10 cut
      $21.99

    Specialty Pizzas

    • Gold Dust Chicken

      Gold dust chicken and mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • The Grandma

      Served only one size. Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, fresh garlic, and plum tomato
      $31.99
    • Buffalo Chicken

      Buffalo sauce, grilled chicken, and mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch

      Grilled chicken, bacon, ranch, and mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • Sicilian Upside Down

      Served only one size
      $25.99
    • Carnivore

      Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, ham, bacon, and mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • Stoner Fry Pizza

      Secret stoner sauce, french fries, bacon & mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • Hawaiian

      Ham, pineapple, bacon and mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • Mac Daddy

      The secret sauce, ground beef, tomato, onion, mozzarella, and American cheese. Topped with lettuce
      $15.99+
    • Tree Hugger

      Tomato, onion, broccoli, garlic, ricotta, and mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • Mac & Cheese

      (May add bacon). Cheddar cheese sauce, pasta, and mozzarella cheese. Topped with breadcrumbs
      $15.99+
    • Philly Steak

      Mushrooms, peppers, onions, white American and mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • PB+J Pizza

      PB+J sauce, crispy chicken & mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • E.B.A (Everything but Anchovies)

      Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, peppers, onions and mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • Popeye's Pie

      Fresh spinach, tomatoes, garlic, ricotta and mozzarella cheese
      $15.99+
    • Balsmic Tuscan Pizza

      $15.99+
    • Gluten Free Grandma

      $17.99
    • BBQ Chicken Pizza

      $15.99+
    • NYS Upside Down Pizza

      $15.99+

    Slice

    • Cheese Slice

      $3.25
    • Pepperoni Slice

      $3.75
    • Gold Dust Slice

      $4.00
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice

      $4.00

    Calzones

    • Original Calzone

      Stuffed with mozzarella and ricotta cheese. Served with a side of marinara
      $12.99
    • Buffalo Chicken Calzone

      Grilled chicken, buffalo sauce, mozzarella cheese & ricotta cheese. Served with a side of blue cheese. Served with blue cheese dressing
      $14.99
    • Gold Dust Calzone

      Grilled or crispy chicken, gold dust sauce, mozzarella & ricotta chesse
      $14.99
    • Godfather Calzone

      Capicola ham, salami, pepperoni, mozzarella & ricotta cheese
      $15.99
    • Stoner Fry Calzone

      Secret stoner fry sauce, french fries bacon, mozzarella cheese & ricotta cheese
      $15.99
    • Philly Cheesesteak Calzone

      Supreme Angus philly steak, mushrooms, peppers, onions, mozzarella & ricotta cheese. Served with a side of marinara sauce
      $16.99
    • Boom Boom Chicken Calzone

      Grilled or crispy chicken, boom boom sauce, mozzarella & ricotta cheese
      $15.99
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Calzone

      Grilled chicken, bacon, ranch, mozzarella cheese & ricotta cheese. Served with a side of ranch
      $15.99
    • Popeye Calzone

      Spinach, tomato, garlic sauce, mozzarella & ricotta cheese
      $15.99

    Pizza & Wing Deals

    • Personal 10" Pizza & 1/2 Dozen Wings

      Cheese or garlic pizza - toppings extra
      $18.99
    • Medium 14" Pizza & 10 Wings

      Cheese or garlic pizza - toppings extra
      $28.99
    • Medium 14" Pizza & 20 Wings

      Cheese or garlic pizza - toppings extra
      $40.99
    • 2 Medium 14" Pizzas & 30 Wings

      Cheese or garlic pizzas - toppings extra
      $65.99
    • Large 16" Pizza & 20 Wings

      Cheese or garlic pizza - toppings extra
      $44.99
    • Large 16" Pizza & 30 Wings

      Cheese or garlic pizza - toppings extra
      $55.99
    • 2 Large 16" Pizzas & 50 Wings

      Cheese or garlic pizzas - toppings extra
      $89.99
    • X-Large 18" Pizza & 50 Wings

      Cheese or garlic pizza - toppings extra
      $79.99

    Wings

    • Wings (10 Pieces)

      Traditional or boneless wings
      $14.99
    • Wings (20 Pieces)

      Traditional or boneless wings
      $29.98
    • Wings (30 Pieces)

      Traditional or boneless wings
      $44.97
    • Wings (40 Pieces)

      Traditional or boneless wings
      $59.96
    • Wings (50 Pieces)

      Traditional or boneless wings
      $74.95
    • Wings (60 Pieces)

      Traditional or boneless wings
      $89.94
    • Wings (6 Pieces)

      Traditional or boneless wings
      $8.99
    • Wings (10 Pieces) (Copy)

      Traditional or boneless wings
      $14.99
    • Wings (10 Pieces) (Copy)

      Traditional or boneless wings
      $14.99

    Appetizers

    • Mozzarella Sticks (7 Pieces)

      With marinara sauce
      $11.99
    • Buffalo Chicken Dip

      With tortilla chips
      $10.99
    • Cheesy Breadsticks

      Add marinara sauce for an additional charge
      $12.99
    • Serious Sampler

      Three mozzarella sticks, three chicken tenders, three boneless buffalo wings, onion petals, and french fries
      $18.99
    • Loaded Tots

      Tater Tots loaded with nacho cheese, bacon and chives served with sour cream
      $9.99
    • Greens

      Our delicious Utica greens
      $10.99
    • Onion Petals

      Served with boom boom sauce
      $9.99
    • Mac N' Cheese Balls

      Served with marinara sauce
      $12.99
    • Sweet Potato Wedges

      With ranch dressing
      $9.99
    • Loaded Fries

      Fries loaded with nacho cheese, bacon and chives served with sour cream
      $9.99
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Quesadilla

      Tortilla stuffed with grilled chicken, bacon, diced tomatoes, and mozzarella cheese
      $12.99
    • Cheese Curds

      Served with marinara sauce and spicy Melba habanero sauce,
      $11.99
    • Super Nachos

      Nachos, nacho cheese, ground beef or grilled chicken, black olives, onions, tomatoes, cherry peppers, sour cream, and mango salsa
      $15.99
    • Buffalo Mozzarella Sticks

      Served with blue cheese dressing
      $12.99
    • Deep Fried Pickles (7 Pieces)

      With boom boom sauce and ranch
      $11.99
    • Garlic Parm Fries

      French fries tossed in our famous garlic sauce topped with Parmesan cheese
      $8.99
    • Pretzel Bites (12 Pieces)

      Dozens pretzel bites served with cheese sauce
      $9.99
    • Buffalo Mac N' Cheese Balls

      Mac n cheese balls topped with buffalo sauce and crumby blue. Served with a side of blue cheese
      $13.99

    Salads

    • Buffalo Chicken Salad

      Lettuce, chopped buffalo chicken tender, tomato, mozzarella cheese, and croutons
      $12.99
    • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

      Romaine lettuce, mozzarella cheese, house Caesar dressing and croutons
      $11.99
    • Boom Boom Grilled Chicken Salad

      Lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, mozzarella cheese and croutons
      $12.99
    • Chef Salad

      Lettuce, tomato, onion, black olives, banana peppers, mozzarella cheese, turkey, ham and croutons
      $12.99
    • Taco Salad

      Tortilla chips, ground beef or grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, cherry peppers, black olives, onions, mozzarella and nacho cheese, sour cream, and salsa
      $12.99
    • BLT Salad

      Lettuce, bacon, tomato, mozzarella cheese and croutons
      $11.99
    • Antipasto Salad

      Lettuce, tomato, onion, black olives, banana peppers, provolone cheese, cappi ham, hard salami, pepperoni and croutons
      $12.99
    • Garden Salad

      Lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, and croutons
      $4.99

    Melts

    • French Dip Melt

      Hormel Angus roast beef, mozzarella cheese, and savory au jus sauce
      $11.99
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Melt

      Crispy chicken, house ranch dressing, tomato & mozzarella chesse
      $11.99
    • Reuben Melt

      Corned beef chunks, Russian dressing, sauerkraut, & Grade A Swiss cheese
      $11.99
    • Buffalo Chicken Melt

      Crispy chicken, medium buffalo sauce, tomato & mozzarella cheese
      $11.99
    • Chicken Parmesan Melt

      Crispy chicken, marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese
      $11.99
    • Steak & Cheese Melt

      Certified Angus sirloin steak, peppers, mushrooms, onion & mozzarella cheese
      $11.99
    • Turkey Bacon Melt

      Antibiotic free roasted turkey, hormel bacon, tomato, & American cheese
      $11.99
    • The Italian Melt

      Authentic cappicola ham, pepperoni, Genoa salami, tomato & provolone cheese
      $11.99
    • Tuna Melt

      Our signature tuna salad, tomato & American cheese
      $11.99
    • Ham & Cheese Melt

      Hormel ham, American cheese and tomato
      $11.99

    Paninis

    • Gold Dust Chicken Panini

      Crispy chicken, gold dust sauce and provolone cheese
      $11.99
    • Godfather Panini

      Authentic cappicola ham, salami, pepperoni, tomato, onion, provolone cheese and pesto mayo
      $11.99
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Panini

      Crispy chicken, tomatoes, provolone, and house ranch dressing
      $11.99
    • Meatball Panini

      Fontinini meatballs, mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce
      $11.99
    • Roast Beef Panini

      Roast beef, tomato, onion, provolone, and pesto mayo
      $11.99
    • Roasted Turkey Panini

      Roasted antibiotic free turkey, tomatoes, onions, provolone, and pesto mayo
      $11.99
    • Chicken Cordon Bleu Panini

      Crispy chicken, hormel ham, Swiss cheese, and honey mustard
      $11.99
    • French Dip Panini

      $11.99
    • Caprese Panini

      $11.99

    Subs & Wraps

    • Boom Boom Chicken Wrap

      Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, pickle, mozzarella cheese & boom boom sauce
      $13.99
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap

      Crispy chicken, lettuce, tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, bacon & ranch dressing
      $13.99
    • Chicken Caesar Wrap

      Grilled chicken, lettuce, mozzarella cheese, and Caesar dressing. Wrap only
      $13.99
    • Buffalo Chicken Wrap

      Crispy chicken, lettuce, tomato, mozzarella cheese and bleu cheese dressing (wrap only)
      $13.99
    • Turkey Sub.

      Antibiotic free turkey
      $11.99
    • Italian Mix.

      Citterio capicola ham, Genoa salami, deli pepperoni and galbani provolone cheese
      $12.99
    • Tuna.

      Our delicious tuna salad recipe
      $11.99
    • Turkey Club.

      Our turkey sub with a toasted roll served with bacon. Antibiotic free, vegetarian grain fed turkey!
      $12.99
    • Chicken Club.

      Toasted served with bacon
      $12.99
    • Mixed.

      Hormel ham, deli pepperoni, Genoa salami & white American cheese
      $11.99
    • BLT.

      Hormel smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo on a toasted sub roll
      $12.99
    • Roast Beef.

      Hormel top round beef
      $11.99
    • Ham.

      Hormel cooked ham
      $11.99
    • Cheeseburger Sub.

      American cheese, lettuce, pickle, onion, mayo, ketchup, and mustard on a toasted roll
      $12.99

    Hot Subs

    • Philly Cheesesteak

      Sirloin Angus steak with mushrooms, peppers, onions & mozzarella cheese
      $12.99
    • Chicken Parmesan Sub

      Crispy chicken, marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese
      $12.99
    • Buffalo Chicken Sub.

      Crispy chicken, buffalo sauce & mozzarella cheese
      $12.99
    • Gold Dust Chicken Sub.

      Crispy chicken, gold dust sauce & mozzarella cheese
      $14.99
    • Reuben

      Corned beef, Russian dressing, sauerkraut & Swiss cheese
      $12.99+
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch

      Crispy chicken, ranch dressing & mozzarella cheese
      $12.99+
    • Steak & Cheddar

      Sirloin Angus steak with mushrooms, peppers, onions & nacho Cheddar cheese
      $13.99+
    • Meatball

      Marinara sauce, meatballs & mozzarella cheese
      $12.99+
    • Fish Sub

      Icelandic beer battered haddock, white American cheese, lettuce & tartar sauce. On a toasted sub roll
      $14.00

    Smash Burgers

    • Deluxe Cheeseburger

      American cheese, pickles, onions, mayo, ketchup & brown mustard
      $13.99
    • Deluxe Bacon Cheeseburger

      Bacon, American cheese, pickles, onions, mayo, ketchup & brown mustard
      $14.99
    • Bleu Burger

      Lettuce and tomato. Topped with blue cheese dressing and crumply blue
      $14.99
    • Boom Boom Burger

      Provolone cheese, pickles, lettuce & boom boom sauce
      $13.99
    • Road House BBQ Bacon Burger

      Topped with onion petals and provolone cheese
      $14.99
    • Bacon, Mushroom & Swiss Burger

      Lettuce and tomato
      $14.99

    Fish, Baskets & Chicken Sandwhiches

    • Chicken Tender Basket (5 Pieces)

      With dipping sauce
      $13.99
    • Fish Fry Dinner

      Served with grandma's coleslaw, fries, tartar sauce, and garlic toast
      $18.99
    • Chicken Sandwich

      Crispy chicken, lettuce, tomato, pickles, American cheese, and mayo
      $13.99
    • Nashville Honey Hot Chicken Sandwich

      Crispy chicken, Nashville honey hot sauce, coleslaw & chopped dill pickles
      $13.99
    • Fish Tacos

      3 beer battered Icelandic haddock fish tacos, coleslaw & remoulade sauce
      $14.99
    • Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

      Crispy chicken, lettuce, tomato, American cheese, and bleu cheese dressing
      $13.99
    • Fish & Chips Basket

      Icelandic beer battered haddock served with tartar sauce or cocktail sauce
      $14.99
    • Boneless Buffalo Wings 7 Pieces

      Dipped in your choice of wing sauce, served with blue cheese dressing
      $7.49
    • Coconut Shrimp Basket

      Seven pieces. Served with mango salsa
      $14.99
    • Fish & Shrimp Dinner

      Served with coconut shrimp, grandma's coleslaw, fries, garlic toast, tartar and mango salsa
      $22.99
    • Fried Clam Basket

      Clam strips served with tartar or cocktail sauce
      $12.99
    • Boom Boom Chicken Sandwich

      Crispy chicken, lettuce, pickles & boom boom sauce
      $13.99
    • Boom Boom Shrimp Basket

      Southern Style Fried Shrimp Tossed in Boom Boom Sauce
      $14.99
    • Shrimp Tacos

      Coleslaw, Lettuce, & spicy remoulade sauce
      $14.99

    Pasta Dinners

    • Chicken Riggies

      Penne pasta, riggie sauce, grilled chicken, sautéed onion, green & cherry peppers
      $19.99
    • Chicken Parmesan Over Ziti

      Penne pasta, marinara sauce, crispy chicken & melted mozzarella cheese
      $18.99
    • Ziti with Meatballs

      Penne pasta, marinara sauce & meatballs
      $17.99
    • Chicken Broccoli Alfredo

      Penne pasta, Alfredo sauce, grilled chicken & broccoli
      $19.99
    • Buffalo Chicken Pasta

      Penne pasta, buffalo pasta sauce, grilled chicken, blue cheese crumbles & mozzarella cheese
      $17.99
    • Baked Ziti

      Penne pasta, marinara sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese
      $16.99
    • Family Baked Pasta

      $24.99

    Sides

    • Garlic Knots

    • French Fries

      $4.99
    • 4 Meatballs

      Served with sauce
      $7.99
    • Seasoned Waffle Fries

      $4.99
    • Tater Tots

      $4.99
    • Nachos

      Served with cheese
      $6.99
    • Garlic Toast

      $4.99
    • Chips & Mango Salsa

      $5.99
    • Curly Fries

      $4.99

    Dipping Sauces

    • BBQ Sauce

      Our BBQ dipping sauce offers a blend of smoky, savory, and slightly sweet flavors, making it an ideal complement for a variety of dishes
      $1.49
    • Blue Cheese Sauce

      A creamy blend of blue cheese typically includes tangy notes and may be enhanced with buttermilk or garlic for a rich dipping experience
      $1.49
    • Blue Hot

      Blue Cheese and Hot Sauce
      $1.49
    • Boom Boom Sauce

      Boom boom sauce typically includes a creamy base with sweet and spicy flavors, often incorporating chili and garlic to create a bold dipping experience
      $1.49
    • Gold Dust Sauce

      Grilled or crispy chicken, gold dust sauce, mozzarella & ricotta cheese, served with gold dust sauce
      $1.49
    • Honey Mustard Sauce

      A blend of sweet honey and tangy mustard, this dipping sauce combines flavors to complement a variety of dishes
      $1.49
    • Hot Sauce

      A spicy blend, typically incorporating chili peppers and other seasonings, ideal for adding a kick to various dishes
      $1.49
    • Inferno Sauce

      $1.49
    • Marinara Sauce

      $1.49
    • Melba Habanero Sauce

      $1.49
    • Mild Sauce

      A cup of our Italian-inspired mild sauce, typically includes a blend of tomatoes and subtle herbs for a smooth taste
      $1.49
    • Nacho Cheese

      Creamy nacho cheese sauce, often enriched with spices for added depth
      $1.49
    • Pesto Mayo Sauce

      Our BBQ dipping sauce offers a blend of smoky, savory, and slightly sweet flavors, making it an ideal complement for a variety of dishes
      $1.49
    • Ranch Sauce

      A creamy blend of buttermilk, herbs, and spices, typically including garlic and onion for a versatile dipping experience
      $2.98
    • Russian Dressing

      $1.49
    • Salsa

      $1.49
    • Sour Cream

      $1.49
    • Sweet n Sour Sauce

      $1.49
    • Sweet n Tangy

      $1.49
    • Tarter Sauce

      $1.49
    • Celery and Blue Cheese

      $3.49

    Desserts

    • Deep-Fried OREOs

      OREOs are enveloped in a light, crisp batter and deep-fried, then typically dusted with powdered sugar
      $5.99
    • Cinni Sweet Sticks

      Our fresh pizza dough stretched 10" topped with cinnamon sugar & hot icing
      $9.99
    • OREO Cream Pie

      An OREO cream pie consists of a cookie crumb crust filled with a smooth, creamy mixture, often featuring chunks of OREO cookies throughout
      $5.99
    • Cannoli

      Flaky pastry filled with a delightful creamy filling, perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth
      $2.99
    • S'mores Cheesecake

      A creamy cheesecake infused with the essence of s'mores, typically includes a graham cracker crust, chocolate chips, and a marshmallow topping
      $6.99
    • Strawberry Cheesecake

      Creamy cheesecake with a strawberry topping, perfect for strawberry lovers
      $6.99
    • Marshmallow Rice Crispy Treat

      A marshmallow rice crispy treat typically consists of melted marshmallows mixed with crispy rice cereal, often resulting in a chewy and slightly crunchy texture
      $3.50
    • Plain Cheesecake

      $5.99
    • Peanut Butter Pie

      OUT OF STOCK
      $5.99

    Drinks

    • 20 Oz Beverages

      Coca-Cola products
      $2.75
    • 2 Ltr Beverages

      Coca-Cola products
      $4.50

    Kids Menu

    • 2 Chicken tenders w/Fries

      served with BBQ sauce
      $7.99
    • Cheese Quesadilla

      served with sour cream
      $7.99
    • 2 Mozzarella Sticks w/ Fries

      served with marinara sauce
      $7.99
    • Noodles w/ Sauce &Parm CHeese

      $7.99
    • Noodles w/ Butter & Parm Cheese

      $7.99

    Catering

    • 100 Chicken Wings

      $125.00
    • 2 Large Cheese & 50 Wings

      $90.00
    • 2 Large Pizzas & 50 Chicken Wings

      $90.00
    • 5 Large Cheese Pizzas

      $75.00
    • 5 Large Cheese Pizzas (toppings extra)

      $75.00
    • Antipasto Roll

      $30.00
    • Antipasto Salad Full Tray

      $75.00
    • Antipasto Salad Half Tray

      $40.00
    • Assorted Sub Platter (30 pc)

      $75.00
    • Baked Ziti w/ Mozzerella Full Tray

      $75.00
    • Baked Ziti w/ Mozzerella Half Tray

      $40.00
    • Buffalo Chicken Roll

      $30.00
    • Celery & Blue Cheese Platter

      $20.00
    • Chicken Ceasar Salad Full Tray

      $75.00
    • Chicken Ceasar Salad Half Tray

      $40.00
    • Chicken Rigges Full Tray

      $110.00
    • Chicken Rigges Half Tray

      $60.00
    • Crispy Chicken Tenders w/ Dip (25 pc)

      $45.00
    • Dinner Rolls with Butter (30 pc)

      $19.00
    • Dozen Cannolis

      $30.00
    • Garden Tossed Salad Full Tray

      $55.00
    • Garden Tossed Salad Half Tray

      $30.00
    • Garlic Bread (30 pc)

      $25.00
    • Garlic Knots (30 pc)

      $25.00
    • Italian Fare

      $11.99
    • Meatballs In Sauce Full Tray

      $90.00
    • Meatballs In Sauce Half Tray

      $55.00
    • Premium Italian Fare

      $14.99
    • Sausage & Peppers Full Tray

      $90.00
    • Sausage & Peppers Half Tray

      $55.00
    • Spinach Roll

      $30.00
    • Stromboli Roll

      $30.00
    • Utica Greens Full Tray

      $110.00
    • Utica Greens Half Tray

      $60.00
    • Utica Tomato Pie

      $17.00

    Mac N' Cheese Balls

    $12.99

    Served with marinara sauce

    Customize your item

    Mozzarella Sticks (7 Pieces) Options

    Optional
    Request advisory
    We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
    1

    All hours
    Sunday10:45 am - 9:00 pm
    Monday10:45 am - 9:00 pm
    Tuesday10:45 am - 9:30 pm
    Wednesday10:45 am - 9:30 pm
    Thursday10:45 am - 9:30 pm
    Friday10:45 am - 9:30 pm
    Saturday10:45 am - 9:30 pm
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy! "You Just Can't Get Enough"

    Location

    9 Clinton St, New York Mills, NY 13417

    Directions