Pizza
Pizza Secret 72 5th Ave
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
INSALATE
ANTIPASTI
Focaccia
Garlic, EVOO • Add Prosciutto +6$9.00
Crocche Napoletani
Potato Croquettes, Smoked Provola$12.00
Arancini
Rice Balls, Bolognese Sauce$14.00Montanarine
Pomodoro & Parmigiano • Cacio e Pepe • Nerano$16.00Mozzarella in Carrozza
Fried Mozzarella, Marinara Sauce$16.00Provola alla Pizzaiola
Smoked Mozzarella, San Marzano Ragù, Parmigiano, Basil$16.00
Polpette della Nonna
Beef Meatballs, Crostini, Ricotta, Parmigiano Fonduta$18.00
Parmigiana
Eggplant, Mozzarella, San Marzano, Parmigiano, Basil$18.00
Bruschettone
Cherry Tomatoes, Stracciatella, Basil, EVOO$16.00Polipo alla Luciana
Octopus, San Marzano, Olives, Capers, Crostini, EVOO$22.00Calamari Fritti
Crispy Calamari, Marinara Sauce, Lemon$20.00Burrata & Parma
Burrata, Prosciutto di Parma, Arugula, Cherry Tomatoes, Crostini, Balsamic Glaze$23.00
SMALL PIZZAS 12"
Margherita 12'
Tomato Sauce, fior di latte, Parmigiano, basil, EVOO.$21.00
Americana 12"
Tomato sauce, fior di latte, pepperoni, hot honey, basil.$23.00Spicy Vodka & Stracciatella
Spicy Vodka Sauce, Smoked Provola, Stracciatella, Parmigiano, EVOO$24.00
Bufala 12"
Buffalo mozzarella, Parmigiano, cherry tomatoes, basil, EVOO.$23.00Provola & Pepe 12'
Cherry tomato sauce, smoked mozzarella, black pepper, basil, EVOO.$24.00Capricciosa
San Marzano Sauce, Mozzarella, Prosciutto Cotto, Mushrooms, Artichokes, Olives, EVOO$25.00Montanara Fritta al Forno
First fried, then baked in the oven. San Marzano Sauce, Mozzarella, Parmigiano, Basil, EVOO$23.00
Cacio e Pepe 12"
Pecorino fondue, fior di latte, black pepper, basil, EVOO.$23.00
Nerano 12"
Fior di latte, zucchini pesto, stracciatella, lemon zest, zucchini chips, basil, EVOO.$26.00Parma 12"
Fior di latte, Parmigiano, arugula, Prosciutto di Parma, Grana Padano, basil, EVOO.$25.00Formaggi & Miele al Tartufo
Fior di Latte, Gorgonzola, Parmigiano, Hot Honey, Truffle Honey, Toasted Walnuts, EVOO$27.00Burrata & Mortadella
Mortadella, Burrata, Pistachio Crumble, Lemon Zest, EVOO$26.00Tartufo
Provola di Bufala, Mushrooms Cream, Mushrooms, Truffle Oil, Parmigiano, Parsley, EVOO$28.00La Figa 12"
Buffalo mozzarella, cooked ham, fig jam, basil, EVOO.$25.00Bandiera
Margherita • Cacio e Pepe • Salsiccia & Friarielli, EVOO$26.00Ripieno al Forno 12"
Ricotta, Napoli salame, smoked provola, tomato, Parmigiano, basil, EVOO.$24.00
Pizza Fritta (Fry Pizza Calzone)
Ricotta, cooked ham, fior di latte, tomato, basil.$23.00
LARGE PIZZAS 18"
Margherita 18"
Tomato, fior di latte, Parmigiano, basil, EVOO.$32.00Americana 18"
Tomato, fior di latte, pepperoni, hot honey, basil.$34.00Bufala 18"
Buffalo mozzarella, Parmigiano, cherry tomatoes, basil, EVOO.$34.00Provola & Pepe 18"
Cherry Tomato Sauce, Smoked Provola, Black Pepper, EVOO$35.00Capricciosa 18"
San Marzano Sauce, Mozzarella, Prosciutto Cotto, Mushrooms, Artichokes, Olives, EVOO$35.00Cacio e Pepe 18"
Pecorino fondue, fior di latte, black pepper, basil, EVOO.$33.00Nerano 18"
Fior di latte, zucchini pesto, stracciatella, lemon zest, zucchini chips, basil, EVOO.$36.00Parma 18"
Fior di latte, Parmigiano, arugula, Prosciutto di Parma, Grana Padano, basil, EVOO.$36.00Burrata & Mortadella
Mortadella, Burrata, Pistachio Crumble, Lemon Zest, EVOO$36.00La Figa 18"
Buffalo mozzarella, cooked ham, fig jam, basil, EVOO.$35.00Ripieno al Forno 18"
Ricotta, Napoli salame, smoked provola, tomato, Parmigiano, basil, EVOO.$35.00Tartufo
Provola di Bufala, Mushrooms Cream, Mushrooms, Truffle Oil, Parmigiano, Parsley, EVOO$38.00
PASTA
Spaghettoni al Pomodoro
San Marzano Tomato Sauce, Basil, EVOO Add Meatballs +7$18.00
Pici Toscani Cacio e Pepe
Pecorino Romano Cream, Black Pepper, EVOO$21.00Fusilloni alla Vodka
Pink Vodka Sauce, Stracciatella, EVOO$24.00Spaghettoni allo Scarpariello
Cherry Tomato Sauce, Garlic, Basil, Pecorino Romano, EVOO$23.00Casarecce Broccoli Rabe
Broccoli Rabe Pesto, Italian Sausage, Pecorino Romano, EVOO$24.00Pappardelle al Ragù
Bolognese Sauce, Parmigiano, EVOO$25.00Paccheri alla Genovese
Slow-Cooked Onion & Short Rib Ragù, EVOO$26.00Ziti alla Nerano
Zucchini Cream, Smoked Provola, Parmigiano, Lemon Zest, Zucchini Chips, EVOO$24.00Lasagna
Ragù Bolognese, Besciamella, Parmigiano, EVOO$25.00Gnocchi alla Sorrentina
San Marzano Sauce, Mozzarella, Basil, EVOO$22.00
Bandiera
$26.00
Margherita • Cacio e Pepe • Salsiccia & Friarielli, EVOO
Customize your item
Select at least 1
Optional
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 12:00 pm - 9:45 pm |
| Monday | 4:00 pm - 10:15 pm |
| Tuesday | 12:00 pm - 10:15 pm |
| Wednesday | 12:00 pm - 10:15 pm |
| Thursday | 12:00 pm - 10:15 pm |
| Friday | 12:00 pm - 10:45 pm |
| Saturday | 12:00 pm - 10:45 pm |
Restaurant info
Pizza Secret is a modern Italian destination inspired by the flavors of Naples and the energy of Brooklyn. Ranked among America’s top pizzerias, we offer award-winning pizza, fresh pasta, craft cocktails, and seasonal Italian specialties. Our mission is simple: exceptional food, warm hospitality, and memorable experiences shared around the table. Welcome to Pizza Secret — where every meal feels like a celebration.
Location