Skip to Main content

  • The Flaming Fish The Flaming Fish - Buffalo

    • Home
    • /
    • Buffalo
    • /
    • The Flaming Fish The Flaming Fish - Buffalo
    • /
    • Online Ordering
    Restaurant banner image

    The Flaming Fish The Flaming Fish - Buffalo

    American
    Closed
    CallDirectionsGift Cards
    MAIN MENU
    BEVERAGES

    Featured Items

    • FISH FRY

      Crispy fried haddock, perfectly seasoned with our signature blend of spices and fried to golden perfection. Served with two house-made sides of your choice and a jalapeño.
      $23.00

    • CRISPY NUGGETS

      CRISPY BEER BATTERED FISH NUGGETS SERVED WITH CHOICE OF FRENCH FRIES OR HUSHPUPPIES.
      $15.00

    • FISH & SHRIMP COMBO

      Crispy fried haddock, paired with golden-fried shrimp, both seasoned with our signature blend of spices. Served with two house-made sides crafted fresh daily, and with a jalapeño cheddar corn muffin- baked in house.
      $30.00

    MAIN MENU

    SPECIALS

    • CRISPY NUGGETS

      CRISPY BEER BATTERED FISH NUGGETS SERVED WITH CHOICE OF FRENCH FRIES OR HUSHPUPPIES.
      $15.00

    SHAREABLES

    • FRIED GREEN TOMATOES

      FRESH GREEN-TOMATOES, PERFECTLY FRIED TO A GOLDEN PERFECTION. TOPPED WITH OUR SIGNATURE SAUCE.
      $15.00

    • SEAFOOD FRIES

      CRISPY SEASONED FRIES SMOTHERED IN MELTED CHEESE AND CROWNED WITH A SEAFOOD MEDLEY. DRIZZLED WITH OUR SIGNATURE SAUCES AND FINISHED WITH FRESH PICO WE GALLO, AND SHREDDED CHEESE AND SOUR CREAM.
      $19.00

    • CRISPY CALAMARI

      CRISPY CALAMARI RINGS SERVED WITH CREAMY SAVORY DIPPING SAUCE.
      $13.00

    • CRISPY MOZZERELLA

      Golden, crunchy perfection on the outside, warm gooey mozzarella on the inside. Served with marinara.
      $11.00

    • QUESADILLA

      A 12" tortilla toasted to perfection and filled with a blend of cheeses, sautéed bell pepper and onions, corn & beans and signature sauce with choice protein.
      $18.00

    • BOMBAY SHRIMP

      A pile of our specially seasoned fried shrimp tossed in our original Bombay sauce served on top of a bed of lettuce and topped with shredded carrots, red cabbage and green onions.
      $17.00

    • VEGGIE QUESADILLA

      $17.00

    CUP & LEAF

    • GUMBO

      Featuring tender chicken, succulent shrimp, and smoked sausage in a slow cooked rich broth.
      $10.00+

    • HOUSE SALAD

      A blend of mixed greens, juicy tomatoes, crisp carrots, tangy banana peppers, shredded cheese, and red onions topped with crunchy croutons. Served with dressing of choice.
      $8.00

    • CAESAR SALAD

      Crisp romaine lettuce, grated parmesan cheese, and crunchy garlic croutons, served with a side of creamy Caesar dressing.
      $9.00

    • STRAWBERRY SALAD

      $10.00

    THE MAINS

    • ANCHORS GLAZED SALMON

      TENDER, FLAKY SALMON TOPPED WITH A VIBRANT BLEND OF VEGETABLES TOSSED IN OUR HOUSE SOY GINGER GLAZE. SERVED WITH BASIL RICE.
      $26.00

    • THE BELTWAY

      GRILLED TILAPIA TOPPED WITH SUCCULENT GRILLED SHRIMP AND TOPPED WITH OUR SIGNATURE SAUCE REMINGTON. SERVED ALONGSIDE OUR RED BEANS AND RICE.
      $24.00

    • HENDRIX MUSHROOM CHICKEN

      CRISPY, GOLDEN-FRIED CHICKEN BREAST SERVED OVER CREAMY GARLIC MASHED POTATOES AND PAIRED WITH TENDER ASPARAGUS. FINISHED WITH A RICH, SAVORY MUSHROOM CREAM SAUCE.
      $25.00

    • JAMBALAYA

      OUR TAKE ON A CREOLE CLASSIC. SAVORY RICE LOADED WITH ONIONS, PEPPERS, AND CELERY. TOSSED WITH TENDER CHICKEN, JUICY SHRIMP, AND SMOKED BEEF SAUSAGE, SMOTHERED IN OUR RICH SAUCE WITH TOMATOES, HERBS, AND BOLD CAJUN SEASONINGS.
      $25.00

    • THE REMINGTON

      HERB-CRUSTED SALMON PAIRED WITH GRILLED SHRIMP, SERVED OVER A BED OF CREAMY GARLIC MASHED POTATOES AND SERVED WITH COLLARD GREENS. FINISHED WITH OUR SIGNATURE SAUCE REMINGTON.
      $35.00

    • THE LEXINGTON

      GRILLED HADDOCK PAIRED WITH SUCCULENT GRILLED SHRIMP, SERVED CREAMY GARLIC MASHED POTATOES AND STEAMED BROCCOLI. FINISHED WITH A CREAMY SPINACH PARMESAN SAUCE.
      $29.00

    • SKIPPERS HERB CRUSTED DINNER

      HERB CRUSTED TILAPIA, PERFECTLY SEASONED AND SERVED OVER A BED OF CREAMY GARLIC MASHED POTATOES. PAIRED WITH TENDER ASPARAGUS.
      $24.00

    PASTAS

    • PASTA LOUIE

      FETTUCCINE PASTA SMOTHERED IN A RICH CREAMY ALFREDO SAUCE WITH SPINACH, PERFECTLY SEASONED. TOPPED WITH CHOICE OF PROTEIN FOR A BOLD FLAVORFUL TWIST ON A CLASSIC FAVORITE.
      $26.00

    • CREAMY CAJUN PASTA

      FETTUCCINE PASTA TOSSED IN OUR BOLD CADIEN CREAM SAUCE, FEATURING GRILLED SALMON, SMOKED BEEF SAUSAGE, SAUTÉED ONIONS, PEPPERS, AND MUSHROOMS. A DELICIOUSLY SPICY AND CREAMY DISH THAT'S SURE TO SATISFY.
      $29.00

    • PICASSO CHICKEN

      A CRISPY, GOLDEN-FRIED CHICKEN BREAST SERVED OVER FETTUCCINE PASTA TOSSED IN RICH MARINARA SAUCE. TOPPED WITH MELTED CHEESE AND BAKED UNTIL HOT AND BUBBLY.
      $24.00

    • PASTA LOUIE - NO PROTEIN

      $17.00

    TACOS

    ALL TACOS SRE SERVED WITH FRENCH FRIES.

    • FIESTA TACO

      Fried or grilled tilapia topped with crisp lettuce, corn salsa, shredded cheese and drizzled with our signature sauce.
      $15.00

    • THE BAHAMA MAMA

      Fried or grilled tilapia topped with crisp lettuce, pico de gallo, and drizzled with our mild signature sauce.
      $15.00

    • SEABREEZE

      FRIED OR GRILLED TILAPIA TOPPED WITH CRISP LETTUCE MANGO SALSA AND DRIZZLED WITH OUR MILD SIGNATURE SAUCE.
      $16.00

    • HADDOCK ALL - IN

      $24.00

    SANDWICHES

    ALL SANDWICHES ARE SERVED WITH FRENCH FRIES.

    • THE CLASSIC FISH SANDWICH

      Choice of Haddock, Catfish, Tilapia, or Whiting, shredded lettuce, tomato, red onion, melted American cheese served on a toasted roll.
      $18.00

    • FISH HOAGIE

      Choice of Haddock, Catfish, Tilapia, or Whiting with sautéed onions and peppers, melted American cheese, and drizzled with our signature sauce.
      $20.00

    • THE CRAB ATTACK

      Two crab cake sliders topped with grilled shrimp, crisp lettuce, juicy tomatoes, melted cheese and our signature sauce.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $25.00

    • CAJUN SALMON SLIDERS

      TWO GRILLED SLIDERS SERVED ON SOFT BUNS WITH CRISP LETTUCE, JUICY TOMATO, RED ONION, AND OUR SIGNATURE SAUCE.
      $20.00

    • FRIED CHICKEN SANDWICH

      CRISPY FRIED CHICKEN BREAST TOPPED WITH LETTUCE, TOMATO, RED ONION, MELTED AMERICAN CHEESE AND OUR SIGNATURE SAUCE.
      $17.00

    • SHRIMP POBOY

      Crispy shrimp piled on a toasted roll, topped with lettuce, tomato, shredded cheese and drizzled with our special sauce.
      $19.00

    • SHORELINE

      A double patty smash burger sucked with a crisp lettuce, juicy tomatoes, sautéed onions and mushrooms, pickles, melted American cheese and our signature sauce.
      $17.00

    FRIED SEAFOOD

    • THE BUFFALO CLASSIC FISH FRY

      Beer battered haddock served with crispy french fries, house-made coleslaw, macaroni salad and a jalapeño cheddar corn muffin with all the fixings. *NO SUBSTITUTIONS*
      $23.00

    • FISH FRY

      Crispy fried haddock, perfectly seasoned with our signature blend of spices and fried to golden perfection. Served with two house-made sides of your choice and a jalapeño.
      $23.00

    • SHRIMP FRY

      10 crispy, golden-fried shrimp, perfectly seasoned with our signature blend of spices. Served with your choice of two house-made sides crafted fresh daily and a jalapeño cheddar corn muffin baked in- house.
      $26.00

    • FISH & SHRIMP COMBO

      Crispy fried haddock, paired with golden-fried shrimp, both seasoned with our signature blend of spices. Served with two house-made sides crafted fresh daily, and with a jalapeño cheddar corn muffin- baked in house.
      $30.00

    • CAPTAINS COMBO

      Crispy fried haddock, 10 shrimp, and calamari perfectly seasoned with our signature blend of spices and fried to golden perfection. Served with a flavorful house-made crab cake, 2 sides, and a jalapeño cheddar corn muffin- baked in house.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $50.00

    SIDES

    • FRENCH FRIES

      $5.00

    • COLESLAW

      $5.00

    • HUSHPUPPIES

      $5.00

    • MACARONI SALAD

      $5.00

    • POTATO SALAD

      $5.00

    • GARLIC MASHED POTATOES

      $5.00

    • BROCCOLI

      $5.00

    • GREEN BEANS

      $5.00

    • CANDIED YAMS

      $5.00

    • COLLARD GREENS

      * cooked with Smoked Turkey
      $5.00

    • RED BEANS & RICE

      $7.50

    • BAKED MACARONI & CHEESE

      $7.50

    • ASPARAGUS

      $7.50

    • FRIED OKRA

      $7.50

    KIDS MEALS

    • KIDS FRIED FISH & FRIES

      $10.00

    • KIDS FRIED SHRIMP & FRIES

      $10.00

    • KIDS CHEESE QUESADILLA & FRIES

      $10.00

    • KIDS CHICKEN QUESADILLA & FRIES

      $10.00

    • KIDS MINI CHEESEBURGERS

      $10.00

    • KIDS CHICKEN STRIPS & FRIES

      $10.00

    DESSERTS

    • PEACH COBBLER BREAD PUDDING

      $12.00

    • SNICKERS PIE

      $7.00

    • CARROT CAKE

      $7.00

    • CHOCOLATE FUDGE CAKE

      $10.00

    • LEMON CREME CAKE

      OUT OF STOCK
      $6.00

    • STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE

      $10.00

    FAMILY MEALS

    • FISH TACKLE BOX

      INCLUDES: 3 PIECES OF PROTEIN OF CHOICE ( WHITING, CATFISH, TILAPIA OR CHICKEN TENDERS), 2 LARGE HOUSE SIDES, AND CHOICE OF JALAPEÑO CHEDDAR CORN MUFFINS OR HUSHPUPPIES. LEMONS AND CONDIMENTS INCLUDED.
      $54.00

    • SHRIMP TACKLE BOX

      INCLUDES: BASKET OF 30 SHRIMP, 2 LARGE HOUSE SIDES, AND CHOICE OF JALAPEÑO CHEDDAR CORN MUFFINS OR HUSHPUPPIES. LEMONS AND CONDIMENTS INCLUDED.
      $63.00

    • COMBO TACKLE BOX

      3 PIECES OF PROTEIN OF CHOICE ( WHITING, CATFISH, TILAPIA OR CHICKEN TENDERS), 20 SHRIMP, 2 LARGE HOUSE SIDES, AND CHOICE OF JALAPEÑO CHEDDAR CORN MUFFINS OR HUSHPUPPIES. LEMONS AND CONDIMENTS INCLUDED.
      $76.50

    A LA CARTE

    • JALAPENO CHEDDAR CORN MUFFIN

      $1.00

    • TOASTED GARLIC BREAD

      $1.00

    • 5 PC. SHRIMP

      $10.00

    • 10 PC. SHRIMP

      $15.00

    • WHITING FILLET

      $7.00

    • PERCH FILLET

      $7.00

    • TILAPIA FILLET

      $8.00

    • CATFISH FILLET

      $10.00

    • CHICKEN FILLET

      $8.00

    • CRAB CAKE

      OUT OF STOCK
      $12.00

    • HADDOCK FILLET

      $18.00

    HOUSE FLAVORS & SAUCES

    • HONEY CAJUN SAUCE

      $2.00

    • HONEY GARLIC LIME SAUCE

      OUT OF STOCK
      $2.00

    • BUFFALO SAUCE

      $2.00

    • BUFFALO LEMON PEPPER SAUCE

      $2.00

    • HOT HONEY SAUCE

      $2.00

    • CAJUN DRY RUB

      $2.00

    • LEMON PEPPER DRY RUB

      $2.00

    • FIESTA SAUCE

      $2.00

    • BAHAMA SAUCE

      $2.00

    • BOMBAY SAUCE

      $2.00

    • FISH HOAGIE SAUCE

      $2.00

    • PO'BOY SAUCE

      $2.00

    • SANDWICH SAUCE

      $2.00

    • HOUSE TARTAR SAUCE

      $0.50

    • KETCHUP

      $0.50

    • HOT SAUCE

      $0.50

    • MUSTARD

      $0.50

    • HOUSE COCKTAIL SAUCE

      $0.50

    • RANCH DRESSING

      $1.00

    • ITALIAN DRESSING

      $1.00

    • CAESAR DRESSING

      $1.00

    • RASPBERRY VINAIGRETTE

      $1.00

    • HONEY MUSTARD

      $1.00

    • SOUR CREAM

      $1.50

    • SAUCE REMINGTON

      $4.50

    BEVERAGES

    • SOFT DRINKS

      $2.95

    • HOUSE LEMONADE

      Fresh squeezed lemonade made in house daily.
      $4.95

    • ARNOLD PALMER

      $3.95

    • HOUSE ICED TEA

      $3.95

    • JUICE

      $3.95

    • COFFEE

      $3.95

    • HOT TEA

      $3.95

    • KIDS BEVERAGES

      $1.95

    • ICE WATER

    • SPARKLING WATER

      OUT OF STOCK
      $1.25
    All hours
    Sunday11:00 am - 8:00 pm
    MondayClosed
    Tuesday4:00 pm - 8:00 pm
    Wednesday4:00 pm - 8:00 pm
    Thursday4:00 pm - 8:00 pm
    Friday11:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Saturday11:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    We can't wait to SEA YOU!

    Location

    535 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14203

    Directions

    Toast logo

    333 Summer Street
    Boston, MA 02210

    © 2026 Toast, Inc.

    • Restaurants by city
    • About Toast
    • Terms of Service
    • For restaurants
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy

    Download our app

    • Download on the App Store
    • Get it on Google Play