
Pizza
Trophy Pizza
10325 Reading Road
Suite 102
Cincinnati, OH 45241
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
ā
ā
ā
Featured Items

20" Plain Cheese Pie
Red sauce, parm, whole milk mozz. Serves 3-5.$23.50
20" Pepperoni Pie
Our best seller. Plain pie topped with cup-and-char pepperoni.$29.75
Grandma Pie
Our delicious pan pizza. Garlic oil base, whole milk mozz, fresh mozz, fresh garlic with sauce, basil and parm on top. Serves 3-5.$27.50
Retail Beverage Menu
Wine

Vignetti Pinot Grigio
A lighter-style Pinot Grigio with plenty of fruit and a nice crip acidity. PERFECT With our #1 Seller NY Cheese Pizza!! (and NY Cheesecake Also...just sayin :) )$15.00
Vignetti Montepulciano
Which wine should you drink with our Pepperoni Pizza?? This one! With Bright, Mouthwatering flavors of cherry, strawberry and sweet spice, this pleasant easy drinking wine is the perfect pizza beverage!$15.00
Vignetti Prosecco
Let's Celebrate PIzza with this awesome, not dry, slightly sweet sparkling gem from Italy. Delicious anytime anywhere! Take care when opening....just sayin!$18.00
Brundimayer Gruner Veltliner
If you are bored with Pinot Grigio, this is the Next wine for you! "LIghtning Clean," dry, medium body, notes of green apple...omg, we love this wine!! Pair it with our White Hot, White Pie and Loophole!! Although great with anything!$25.00
Galactica Sauvignon Blanc
Sauv Blanc from Chile?? YES! Light, Fresh, Lemon, Chamomile, MIneral...omg I love this wine. Please, do not tell Jim it isn't from New Zealand....it will be our secret!$13.00
Alturis Italian Chardonnay
$20.00
Familia Furotti Malbec
OK - almost 6yrs old..Vineyard is over 1/2 mile above sea level...Vines planted in 1936...ONLY 3000 cases produced...light oak contact....Open this wine and give it some air....flavors will last on your palate a long time. Pair this with our Arthur Avenue and Saucy Sausage Pie! Holy Smokes this wine is something else!!$21.00
Sean Minor Cabernet Sauvignon
California Cabernet Sauvignon! Do I need to say more?? Ok, I will! Blackberry, Red and Black Currant, hints of roasted coffee, earthy, complex but with toasty rich fruit. Do you like Red Wine?? We do!! This wine is for US!$21.00
Broc Cellars Amore Rosso
Jeff's pick! Organically grown grapes in Nort hern Californian, this wine is made from Italian Varietals. Barbara, Dolcetto, Negro Amaro and a little Nebbiolo. Wine style is kinda like a Pinot Noir but this elegant sophisticated wine is perfect for our Margherita Pizza and, omg yes, the Trophy Pizza!$32.00
Yes Way Rose
YEEEESSSS WAY! Light, easy to drink, not sweet and perfect - yes perfect -for the Yes Way Pizza! This French winery produces ONLY Rose. You will like!$20.00
PInot Project Pinot Grigio Can
$5.00
Pinot Project Rose Can
$5.00
Pinot Project Pinot Noir Can
$5.00
Ravines Dry Riesling NY
$25.00
Beer

6pk Miller Lite
$8.99
12pk Coors Banquet
$14.99
12pk Bells Two Hearted Ale
$21.99
6pk Peroni
$11.99OUT OF STOCK
12pk Garage Beer
$16.99
8pk Little Kings Cream Ale
$10.99OUT OF STOCK
6pk Brooklyn Lager
$9.99
12 pk Mad Tree Legendary
$18.99
12 pk Peroni
$19.99
6pk Mad Tree Seeing Colors IPA
$11.9912 pk Bud Light
$11.9912 pk Modelo
$15.996pk Paulaner Hefe-Weizen
$11.99
12 Pk Peroni
$19.994 pk 16oz Bells Hop Slam
$16.99OUT OF STOCK
Food
Classic Pies

20" Plain Cheese Pie
Red sauce, parm, whole milk mozz. Serves 3-5.$23.50
20" Margherita Pie
Perhaps our favorite slice. Red sauce, fresh mozz, a pinch of whole milk mozz, basil and fresh parm. Drizzled with extra virgin olive oil.$25.50
20" White Pie
A beautiful pizza experience. White pie with mozz, ricotta, caramelized onions and fresh basil.$27.50
20" Pepperoni Pie
Our best seller. Plain pie topped with cup-and-char pepperoni.$29.75
20" Round Grandma
Some people call it a Tomato Pie. A 20" pie built Grandma style with fresh mozz and sauce fresh garlic and basil on top.$29.75
Grandma Pie
Our delicious pan pizza. Garlic oil base, whole milk mozz, fresh mozz, fresh garlic with sauce, basil and parm on top. Serves 3-5.$27.50
Pepperoni Grandma Pie
Our classic grandma pie with cup & char pepperoni. Try it with a side of our house made ranch.$31.25
Specialty Pies

20" Saucy Sausage Pie
A margherita pie with ricotta, sausage and fresh garlic.$35.50
20" Arthur Avenue
Plain slice topeed with pepperoni, sausage and bacon.$36.50
20" Yes Way
Plain slice topped with capicola, sausage, banana peppers and red onion.$34.00
20" Loophole
A bacon, chicken, ranch slice ratcheted up with jalapeƱos and caramelized onions.$34.00
20" White Hot
Hot honey drizzled on a white based pie with capicola, pepperoni, ricotta, whole milk & fresh mozz.$36.50
20" Pollo Loco
Vodka sauce over a white based pie with chicken, jalapeƱos and red onion.$35.50
20" Vodka Meatball
A white pie with ricotta and caramelized onions and topped with fresh arugula, prosciutto, parm and extra virgin olive oil.$36.50
20" Peppery Pig
Our white pie topped with fresh arugula and prosciutto.$36.50
20" Trophy Pie
Plain our way: add fresh mozz and a little extra sauce.$29.50
Calzones

Cheese Calzone
Our hand stretch dough folded and baked to crispy perfection around mozz, ricotta, romano and parmesan and served with a side of our tomato gravy. Serves 2-3.$15.25
Deluxe Calzone
Our hand stretch dough folded and baked to crispy perfection around mozz, ricotta, romano and parmesan and your choice of up to four fillings. Served with a side of our red sauce Serves 2-3.$19.75
Other Pies
20" Custom Flat Rate Pie
*IMPORTANT* Use this item ONLY to order 20" pies that exceed $37.50 when using regular pies. Add your choice of up to five toppings.$37.50Flate Rate Grandma Pie
*IMPORTANT* Use this item ONLY to order Grandma pies that exceed $37.50 using the Classic Grandma item. Add your choice of up to five toppings.$37.5020" Specialty Half & Half Pie
*IMPORTANT* Use this item ONLY to order pies with halves that have different bases or are specialty pizzas. For normal half & half pies, choose the pie you want in our Classic Pies menu.$23.50
Gluten Free Pies
12" Gluten Free Plain Pie
Red sauce, parm, whole milk mozz. Serves 1-2.$17.2512" Gluten Free Margherita Pie
Perhaps our favorite slice. Red sauce, fresh mozz, a pinch of whole milk mozz, basil and fresh parm. Drizzled with extra virgin olive oil. Serves 1-2.$19.2512" Gluten Free White Pie
A beautiful pizza experience. White pie with mozz, ricotta, caramelized onions and fresh basil. Serves 1-2.$19.7512" Gluten Free Pepperoni Pie
The best seller. Plain slice topped with cup-and-char pepperoni. Serves 1-2.$20.5012" Gluten Free Arthur Avenue
Plain pie topeed with pepperoni, sausage and bacon. Serves 1-2.$22.5012" Gluten Free Yes Way
Plain slice topped with capicola, sausage, banana peppers and red onion. Serves 1-2.$21.5012" Gluten Free Loophole
A bacon, chicken, ranch slice ratcheted up with jalapeƱos and caramelized onions. Serves 1-2.$21.5012" Gluten Free White Hot
Hot honey drizzled on a white based pie with capicola, pepperoni, ricotta, whole milk & fresh mozz. Serves 1-2.$21.5012" Gluten Free Pollo Loco
Vodka sauce over a white based pie with chicken, jalapeƱos and red onion. Serves 1-2.$21.5012" Gluten Free Vodka Meatball
A white pie with ricotta and caramelized onions and topped with fresh arugula, prosciutto, parm and extra virgin olive oil. Serves 1-2.$21.5012" Gluten Free Peppery Pig
Our white pie topped with fresh arugula and prosciutto. Serves 1-2.$22.5012" Gluten Free Round Grandma
Some people call it a Tomato Pie. A 12" Gluten Free pie built Grandma style with fresh mozz and sauce fresh garlic and basil on top. Serves 1-2.$19.7512" Gluten Free Flat Rate Pie
Choose your base and cheeses then up to five toppings. Serves 1-2.$24.50
Salads

Caesar Salad
Romaine, croutons, homemade Caesar dressing, freshly grated parmesan. Serves 1-2$11.25
Benshonhurst Salad
Mixed greens, kalamata olives, prosciutto, fresh grated parm, red onions, grape tomatoes and croutons. Choice of dressing. Serves 1-2$13.75
Fresh & Cool Salad
Mixed greens, tomato, onion, cucumbers, croutons. Choice of dresing. Serves 1$10.25
Seasonal Salad
Mixed greens, dried cherries, goat cheese, toasted almonds and red onion with apple basil vinaigrette.$13.25
Half Caesar Salad
Romaine, croutons, homemade Caesar dressing, freshly grated parmesan. Serves 1.$7.25
Half Fresh & Cool Salad
Mixed greens, tomato, onion, cucumbers, croutons. Choice of dresing. Serves 1$6.50
Caesar Salad for 10
Serves 10+ side salads.$46.50
Fresh & Cool Salad for 10
Serves 10+ side salads.$42.50
Bensonhurst Salad for 10
Serves 10+ side salads.$52.50
Meatballs

3 Meatballs & Sauce
Three of our homemade meatballs with red sauce and topped with fresh parmesan and basil. Meatballs are made with veal, pork, and beef, egg, ricotta cheese, garlic, and parsley.$8.95
6 Meatballs & Sauce
Six of our homemade meatballs with red sauce and topped with fresh parmesan and basil. Meatballs are made with veal, pork, and beef, egg, ricotta cheese, garlic, and parsley.$16.50
Dessert
Snacks
Drinks
Non-Alcoholic Drinks

Fountain Drink
$2.95
Mexican Coke
Coca-Cola Original Taste ā the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love$3.50
Mexican Fanta Orange
Liberate your every day with fizzy and refreshing fruit-flavored Fanta soda pop$3.50
Mexican Sprite
Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free$3.50
Boylan's Black Cherry Soda
$3.50
Boylan's Creamy Red Birch Beer
$3.50
Boylan's Ginger Ale
$3.50
Boylan's Grape Soda
$3.50
Boylan's Cream Soda
$3.50
Boylan's Classic Seltzer
$3.50
Coca-Cola, 12oz Can
Coca-Cola Original Taste ā the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love$2.00
Diet Coke, 12oz Can
Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink$2.00
12 oz. Can of Dr. Pepper
$2.00
Sprite, 12oz Can
Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free$2.00
Coca-Cola Zero Sugar, 12oz Can
Enjoy the great taste of Coca-Cola with zero sugar, zero calories$2.00
San Pellegrino Sparkling Water
$3.00
San Pellegrino Blood Orange Soda
$3.00
San Pellegrino Pomegranate & Orange Soda
$3.00
San Pellegrino Lemon Soda
$3.00
Gold Peak Sweetened Black Tea
Sweetened with real cane sugar for a deliciously real brewed sweet tea$3.00
Gold Peak Unsweetened Tea
Real Brewed Tea with no sugar for a zero calorie, unsweet tea$3.00
Bottled Water
$1.75
Meal Deal Drink
Beer & Seltzer
Madtree light lager
$4.00Madtree Seeing Colors
$5.00Brooklyn Special Effects Non Alch
$5.00Althletic Run Wild IPA
$5.00Bell's Two Hearted IPA
$5.00High Noon Peach
$7.00Brooklyn Lager
$5.00Modelo
$4.00Miller Lite
$4.00Michelob Ultra
$4.00Peroni
$5.00Coors Banquet Stubby Bottle
$3.75Paulaner Hefe-Weizen
$5.50Bells Hop Slam
$6.00OUT OF STOCKStella Artois
$4.50

20" Pepperoni Pie
$29.75
Our best seller. Plain pie topped with cup-and-char pepperoni.
Customize your item
20" Red Pie Changes
Select up to 4
Bake Instructions
Select up to 2
20" Whole Toppings
Select up to 4
Extras
Select up to 3
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 10:15 am - 8:00 pm |
| Monday | 10:15 am - 8:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 10:15 am - 8:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 10:15 am - 8:00 pm |
| Thursday | 10:15 am - 8:00 pm |
| Friday | 10:15 am - 9:00 pm |
| Saturday | 10:15 am - 9:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Trophy Pizza is Cincinnati's original, authentic New York pizza joint. We've been delivering the freshest, most delicious pizza, salads & desserts with a smile, for an incredible value since 2023. Perfect for a quick, affordable lunch or for a party of 100+, we have all your pizza cravings covered.
Location








